Ding-Dong, the Twinkie is Dead: Were Labor Unions to Blame for Hostess' Downfall?
By now, I’m sure you have heard about the demise of Hostess, and with it that of the infamous Twinkie. But there is far more to this story than the impending lack of America’s favorite cream-filled sponge cake. More specifically, this turn of events involves Hostess going before a bankruptcy judge, asking for permission to go out of business and lay off 18,500 workers. At the root of Hostess’ bankruptcy motion involves a long-fought battle between union workers and top executives. It should be noted that this is not merely the story of one company shutting its doors; it symbolizes an argument between two drastically different groups, involving issues of compensation for top executives, workers’ rights, and income equality in general.
On one hand, there’s the workers.
Hostess has been making unreasonable demands. They have not only cut wages and benefits for about one-third of workers, but they have also given top executives large pay raises. Union president Frank Hurt says that “our members were aware that while the company was descending into bankruptcy and demanding deep concessions, the top ten executives of the company were rewarding themselves with lavish compensation increases, with the then CEO receiving a 300 percent increase.” Also, Hostess has been mismanaged for some time, in addition to being loaded down with debt from private equity firms, yet they choose to place the blame on union members. Moreover, if union members had not made wage and concessions after their first bankruptcy, this company would have shut its doors a long time ago. Since this bankruptcy, senior management and top executives have failed to turn the company around and make it profitable. Any smart company would invest more money into marketing, new technology, and other potential paths to success following a bankruptcy, but Hostess did not do this.
And the other, the business.
It is far better to have a job with reduced benefits and wages than to have no job at all, which is something that the striking Hostess workers should have learned by now. By going on strike and demanding more than the company could give, they drove Hostess out of business, and now more than 18,000 people are out of work. It is more than obvious that pro-union politics are bad for business. As Ted Nugent wrote in an article for the Washington Times about Hostess’ demise, “businesses are not social welfare experiments whose primary responsibility is to provide jobs and meet the demands of ever-shrinking labor unions…[but] there is good news. In the private sector, labor unions are quickly becoming extinct. Only about 7 percent of private-sector employees belong to labor unions.” This is indeed a good sign, as labor unions often cause large companies to fail. In fact, it is often because of labor unions and their fantastical demands that companies leave the United States, and that union-heavy states often have weaker economies than ones with less unionized workers. It is abundantly clear that if we want to create – and maintain – jobs in America, we need to realize that reducing union presence is the first priority. We don’t need the America of the 1950s, with one-third of citizens belonging to labor unions. We need workers who are willing to embrace pro-business ideals, and who will be willing to have their wages and benefits cut if that’s what is needed to keep the company afloat. If Hostess union workers had come to this realization and backed down, the company would be in business, and 18,000 people wouldn’t be out of work.
But which is right?
As Paul Krugman writes in his recent article for the New York Times, “in 1955 roughly a third of American workers were union members…America in the 1950s made the rich pay their fair share; it gave workers the power to bargain for decent wages and benefits; yet contrary to right-wing propaganda then and now, it prospered.” Clearly, a country where workers are given the right to voice their demands in the form of unions and in which the wealthy are held accountable can not only do merely alright; it can succeed. Although increased income equality and more presence workers’ voices are obviously not a priority or in the best interest for everyone, both will benefit the majority. Just because the minority has the money and power does not mean they should have the right to continually run companies into the ground while pinning the blame on labor unions, as they only seek to further their own interests.
In the end, union members “decided that they were not going to agree to another round of outrageous wage and benefit cuts and give up their pension only to see yet another management team fail and Wall Street vulture capitalists and ‘restructuring specialists’ walk away with untold millions of dollars.” Union members did not accept this behavior from corporate elite, and Americans should not either. Enough is enough.
What do you think about the controversy surrounding Hostess’ bankruptcy? Sound off below!
Apply to Write for Uloop NewsJoin the Uloop News Team
Discuss This Article
More Uloop Business Articles
Recent DU News Articles
RECENT DU CLASSIFIEDS
WRITE FOR ULOOPApply to Write for Uloop News
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
TOP 5 NEWS ARTICLES
BROWSE OTHER COLLEGES
- By CollegeUniversity of Colorado at BoulderColorado State UniversityMetropolitan State University of DenverUniversity of DenverUniversity of Northern ColoradoRegis UniversityColorado CollegeUniversity of Colorado at DenverFort Lewis CollegeColorado School of MinesWestwood CollegeUniversity of Colorado at Colorado SpringsAdams State CollegeColorado Christian UniversityColorado State University-PuebloColorado Technical UniversityColorado Technical University OnlineJones International UniversityColorado Mesa UniversityNaropa UniversityThe Art Institute of ColoradoUnited States Air Force AcademyUniversity of Colorado at Denver and Health Sciences CenterWestern State College of ColoradoAims Community CollegeColorado Mountain CollegeCommunity College of Aurora Community College of Denver Northeastern Junior College Pueblo Community College Academy of Natural Therapy IncAmerican Sentinel UniversityArgosy University-DenverAspen UniversityAuguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts-BoulderAveda Institute-DenverBel-Rea Institute of Animal TechnologyCheeks International Academy of Beauty Culture-Fort CollinsCheeks International Academy of Beauty Culture-GreeleyCollege of International Esthetics IncCollegeAmerica-Colorado SpringsCollegeAmerica-Fort CollinsColorado Academy of Veterinary TechnologyColorado Heights UniversityColorado School of Traditional Chinese MedicineColorado Technical University-Greenwood VillageConcorde Career College-AuroraDelta Montrose Technical CollegeDeVry University-ColoradoEcotech InstituteEmily Griffith Technical CollegeEmpire Beauty School-AuroraEmpire Beauty School-LittletonEverest College-AuroraEverest College-Colorado SpringsHealing Arts InstituteHeritage College-DenverIliff School of TheologyInstitute of Taoist Education and AcupunctureIntellitec College-Colorado SpringsIntellitec College-Grand JunctionIntellitec Medical InstituteInternational Salon and Spa AcademyITT Technical Institute-WestminsterJohnson & Wales University-DenverLincoln College of Technology-DenverMontage AcademyMontessori Casa InternationalMontessori Education Center of the RockiesNational American University-Colorado SpringsNational American University-Colorado Springs SouthNational American University-DenverNational Beauty CollegeNational Personal Training Institute of ColoradoNazarene Bible CollegeNew Dimensions Beauty Academy IncOtero Junior CollegePickens Technical CollegePikes Peak Community CollegePima Medical Institute-AuroraPlatt College-AuroraPrince Institute-Rocky MountainsRedstone CollegeRegency Beauty Institute-Fort CollinsRocky Vista UniversityRolf Institute of Structural IntegrationThe Salon Professional Academy-Grand JunctionTrinidad State Junior CollegeUnited Beauty CollegeUniversity of the RockiesUtah College of Massage Therapy-AuroraUtah College of Massage Therapy-WestminsterYeshiva Toras Chaim Talmudical Seminary
- By State
- By City